Jimmy, I can relate a story I do know of personally:
A late friend was a fabulous fiddle player, a 5-string fiddle no less (only man I ever saw who could play TRIPLE stops in tune (!) on a violin). Did some song demo sessions that went downtown to the label. Songs went in the round file, but the staff producer wanted to know 'what box is that guy using' to get that fabulous fiddle sound.
Well, Jim would only record with his orchestra grade fiddles: Serious violins, no pickup, different than his stage fiddles which were padded for feedback, pickups, etc. He'd record his parts in a small, hard wall room with his C414 AKG, and that was all. He thought great tone + great mic was all you need. Little reverb at the board, done. So the label sends a guy out to watch him cut, who followed his signal path across the room, thru the wall, and behind the console, only to climb out and say 'He's NOT using ANYTHING!'.
A few weeks later Jim's on a session and he keeps hearing these great-sounding string pads from the keyboard guy. The guy smiles and thanks him for the compliment, then thanks Jim, as it's HIM sampled from previous dates.
J o e y