Pat:
I too am a picky PITA when it comes to tone. I'm never quite satisfied with anything. As such, I've found there is no such thing as something that can do multiple tasks equally as exceptional (try using a Leatherman or Swiss Army Knife to get my drift, LOL!). Amps are no different. I use multiple amps because I can't get everything I want in one amp.
Having said that, you would be surprised at how versatile my Straub amp is. Ever hear a plexi or plexi-style amp play clean and with headroom? My Straub does! Then you crank up the gain and look out...it's Angus without the additional stage in the circuit and EvH with the boost knob pulled! In a pinch, I could get by with just this amp...it's that good and that versatile. Harry Straub knows his stuff and is anal about tube tone. The clean minimalist design, coupled with meticulous attention to detail and high-tolerance premium parts has resulted in a winner, IMHO...and all for the price of a mass-market GC head!!!
Even still, I have my Twin for the clean stuff. BTW, don't sell Fender's short...they need a little tweaking to sound good. You'd be surprised what a good cab and speakers will do for an overly brite, tinny Silverface twin. Remember, Garcia used a Silverface as his pre-amp, and actually preferred it to his back-up blackface twin. Of course, he used a Mac S/S power amp and a trio of JBL D-120's to clean-up the sound, as it were. He took the same approach as Gilmour, just using different equipment: clean amp with hi-headroom and get your dirt using effects. He happened to use Hiwatts with Fanes, but he had an Alembic F-2B (moddded Fender Showman tube circuit)as a pre-amp. Oh yeah...and those Pete Cornish custom pedalboards he uses (TENS of thousands each!) contributed a little too, LOL!
Regardless, I write too much, LOL!
The moral of the story:
Play EVERYTHING and make up your own mind! You may find one amp that is a good compromise for you. But if you're anal about tone, you may have to resign yourself to having to use multiple amps to get what you want. Just my $0.02
Cheers,
Kevin
BTW, SRV used multiple amps plus effects plus endless guitar tweaks and, oh yeah, he was a one-of-a-kind player with little, if any, equal. Also, ck out dozin.com for Jerry's rig and gilmourish.com for David's rig...you'll find they spent a LOT of time and money finding the MOUNTAINS of equipment it took to get their respective tones.
(Message edited by kmh364 on December 27, 2005)