Hey 0vid,
The Fatboy in bridge position is absolutely brilliant for slapping, but for regular fingerstyle I really-really-really miss the clear highs from the AXY ... or at least I think I do. I have to max the Q switch (6dB in my case) and boost the highs on my SWR to get the same brightness as with the AXY, which I can run with zero Q and a lot less boost on the amp. I'm comparing with fairly new DR LowRiders, so I wouldn't think it's the strings.
The Fatboy also overwhelms the AXY in the neck position, no matter what I try with the blend pot. I'll play around with pickup heights and trimpots some more, see if that can improve things. I'll also put on some old strings to see if there will be any highs left in that situation.
Final option would be to see what the Fatboy can deliver in the neck position. Right now, I get more brightness from the neck AXY than from the bridge Fatboy!
I'm wondering if this could be due to the koa top on my Spoiler, which is supposed to be a little less bright than other woods. Perhaps the Fatboy would be great with a brighter top like maple.