(a couple of others responded while I was writing, and I like what they say)
Jordan, I do not speak for Alembic. The views I express here are simply those of a very satisfied customer, and as someone who has visited them in person several times (and thinks it's been too long since my last visit, because I miss them).
I did my best to understand your question, and I think that I do - but perhaps I didn't phrase my response as well as I might have. I'll try again, but I'm not sure I can do much better.
This is a family operation. These are people that pour their love into the instruments they build, and give it their all. They do this out of personal commitment, not legal obligation. That's sort of a way of life for some people - the kind of people I tend to respect most highly - and I believe it is directly responsive to you question.
You said, I understand Alembic has the backing, but I'm not convinced you really do. In the rest of your life, there must be a few people that you know will come through for you, when you need it, without regard to what it costs them. They don't write this down in a legal contract for you; somehow or other you establish a sense of committment and trust that you feel comfortable with. And yeah, sometimes they get a little tied up with other stuff, but they will eventually come through for you, without having to take them to court, and you know it.
I don't know what else to say here. You've said that I know they provide customers with excellent service after the one year period. If you need that in writing, then I wouldn't hold your breath. But if you know it already, then I guess I truly don't understand the question.
Take your time. Look around, think about what's really important to you, and decide when you're ready. If you think Alembic might be right for you, but you're still a little nervous, then you might try to find a fairly inexpensive used instrument, maybe with a beat up finish or something. See how you like it, give them a call and talk about it. Just see how it goes, and what your level of trust is.
People seem to squirm out of legal difficulties all the time. But as I said originally, as long as you're nice about it (and in fact, even if you're not quite as pleasant and patient as you really should be), in my experience you're going to have a hard time finding another company that will take care of you in the same way, regardless of the warranty.
-Bob
(Message edited by bob on November 21, 2006)