rrbass:
My gosh, this is SOOO subjective . . .
Chasing the sound in your head thru the choices we make for amps, boy this could fill a LARGE book. And there is no 'right' answer ! So here's some random thoughts looking back over my 25 years:
I see basically two fundamental choices:
1) The basic, fat, less than surgically-clean tone of an old Precision thru a creaky SVT (or any combination that's similar)
2) ...or the REAL clean rig you went to after that: preamp, power amp, cabinet (maybe biamped).
With #1, you're loud enough, but where's the articulation? With #2, now I hear EVERYTHING (gee, I never heard all this FRET NOISE / PICKUP HUM / HISS with the Peavey head ! !), but it's so clean it doesn't sound like it's that loud.
By now, you're sick of calling Allied Van Lines to move your rig, so . . . gee, these ACMEs are nice and small (or 210s, 212s, 410s) . . .
See where this is going? You can 'logical' yourself to the poor house. So, find a tone that's 'you' and build out from there. Always buy more watts than you need. Stick with companies that have been around. Remember that the tones you hear on recordings or in concert are HEAVILY processed in ways that aren't usually reproduceable live with just you and an amp and effect. Always buy the best you can afford, all the way down to good cords.
I recently bought the MESA Venture combo 210 with an add-on MESA 115 cabinet. It's got 'my' tone, MESAs are built to withstand WW3, and it's easy to move, with more than enough watts to fill my needs. This is what I liked out of many choices I could have made.
I'd love to have an f2b, sf2, Lexicon, Crown, BagEnd/ELF component rig, but my life just doesn't require/justify it. THAT would be the ultimate ALEMBIC rig for me, but I don't need 'that much amp' any more.
J o e y