Okay. I've got a bit of a dilemma and I just realized this is the perfect place for it. I want to talk about pickups and I barely know what the hell I'm talking about, and I know there are wizards here who do.Just to get directly at the issue in a purely aural manner, please listen to
this, in particular to the sound of the pickup itself. Your careful consideration is is appreciated.
Then listen to
this.
Same pickup: the original Gretsch Filtertron.
But I didn't know it until about an hour ago, when I happened upon
the story of Pete Townsend's Gretsch 6120, which he used on every track of "Who's Next" and every album thereafter. "Tommy." "Quadrophenia." Etc.
Part of the confusion is that he used it to record the songs but seldom used it live - especially after he smashed it to smithereens on live TV ("I accidentally trod on it," he says, with photographic proof that his definition of "trod" is; "smacked that baby into the stage like a railroad spike") and then had it painstakingly restored. Must be nice, huh?

This has me baffled. One minute minute I'm listening to Chet's pristine dulcet tones and the next I'm confronted with the fact that I've been listening to the exact same pickups for a half-century and didn't even know it, and that version sounded like somebody whippin' the strings with a straight-razor or stomping on a box of cornflakes.
What little I do know about Filtertrons comes mostly from Chet's final book; "
Me and My Guitars," and the problem there is that I bought the limited edition "CGP" version and it's still sealed in its numbered presentation box, etc., (for the day Pappy needs new shoes, if you follow my drift). I finally read the book when the paperback version came out a few years later, then cheerfully gave it to a friend. Now the paperback version goes for over $350 and I'm ska-rood as far as finding out what Chet had to say about 'em, because like I said from the get-go: I don't know squat about pickups, other than "Sonicus' Dictum: '
Know your flux density.'" (And I don't even know what that means. Know'm sayin'?)
So all this preamble was just to say that I knew that George Harrison, John Lennon, Eddie Cochran and Brian Setzer all used Gretsch guitars because Chet did, period. (They said so.) Townsend did so because Joe Walsh gave him a '58 with the original Filtertrons in it. He plugged it in and the rest is windmilling history.
so what is it about Filtertrons?