Joey:
I got that one (NYR&SR) about five years back. It's very good. That was supposedly the seed that grew into the 93 SD reunion tour, and the subsequent '96, '00, and '02 tours.
Bear in mind I am not the Japanese bike expert I used to be, and the fact that I am primarily a street bike (i.e., Harley) rider. That said, beating the KLR for the dollar @ $5199 is tough. There's lots of aftermarket parts/accessories/upgrades available for it as well. At that price range you've ruled out the more exotic (and expensive) Dakar Rally-winning KTM's and BMW's. Honda's XR650L @ $5499 ('04 price) is a decent bike, and Honda is among the best in reliability, engineering, and fit/finish in the industry (the R model-version has won the Baja so many times I've lost count). Suzuki's DR650SE is $4999, and isn't a bad bike.
Bear in mind that those are MSRP's, so visit the dealers and make a deal while we're still in Winter. They're also bound to have leftover new models, so you can save even more dosh with a little effort. Don't rule out the web either: Competition Accessories out in Ohio (a dealer for all Jap makes and Ducati) makes killer deals over the net/phone and they will ship. They have great prices on parts/accesories as well, particularly on OEM parts.
Try the web for reviews of the above if you're undecided. Motorcycle Consumer News is a great resource, but there are a lot of magazines that cater to the Japanese bike market, like Cycle World or Motorcyclist that will have back reviews as well (the nearby public library may have back issues as well).
BTW, Whitehorse Press sells KLR accesories and they also have that Jerry Motorman Palladino video that is similar to what the MSF experienced rider course teaches, but is more intense. Highly recommended to save your bacon on the road. Don't forget to take an MSF course as soon as you can....you may thank me later, LOL! You may also wish to try the Danny Walker Supercamp course. Grand National Dirt Track style-riding (dirt circle, left turns only, steel shoe on left foot while dragging it in the dirt at speed!)on Honda XR-100's at 10/10's! That'll teach you how to slide that beast of a DP bike on the dirt. Enjoy!
(Message edited by kmh364 on March 12, 2005)