Your average sizzle on an LP will be caused by dirt seated in the groove. But anyway, you need to look at the whole chain of reproduction, not just the start. And I'm not even talking recording techniques here ... though I do recommend making your own recordings on a digital tape recorder, perhaps an old Sony PWM module with a VHS machine for storage, in a controlled environment with only your own instruments, in a climate controlled ... etc, etc.
For sizzle, I recommend 1980s speakers of just about any German manufacturer.
For mid burp and no low or high end response to speak of, 1980s Tannoy.
For pure bliss, Quad electrostats with a meaty tube power amp.
