I've had a few hobgoblins and scarecrows, and I must say I didn't like it, at all. I'm very, very picky about my brews, though.. I personally liked the Fiddler's elbow more than the Hobgoblin and Scarecrow... and I don't think it tastes like sam adams... but i guess variety (differences in opinion) is the spice of life. I still stand by my previous suggestion that you can't beat a New Belgium ale.
Oh well... a toast to opinions, and good beer!!
Austin