It would be much better if this became an archive thread than a beer thread. We've had almost a week of discussion on the topic and I think all the regulars have had a read of it if not a response. There may be some uncovered ground out there, but I think the various posters have said everything that needs saying.
For any new person coming in, this isn't among the first threads I would want them to read, but of course that's just my opinion. If you're in agreement, though, let's try not to keep this thing bumped to the top of the list any longer than is necessary. Diverting to beer or motorcycles will just keep the rest of it around that much longer. Not to mention that threadjacking is impolite.