I've found that if you can exercise restraint, having too much power is always best. That way, it's always clean and most speakers can take clean peaks if they are of short duration. Running an amp up against its limits can blow speakers pretty easily, even if it's of lower power.
Just use your ears and if it sounds like the speakers are having difficulty (popping and farting) just turn it down. Or turn down the low end. I use a QSC CV1202v, which is the install equivalent of the top of the old Powerlight line. 700 watts per channel into 8 ohms and something like 2000 watts into 8ohms bridged mono. I used to run it bridged, but it's too easy to get enthusiastic and let the magic smoke out of the speakers. You can hear it coming, but it's too hard for me to resist.