You guys make great points. As for me, listening to great works from other bassist, I often wonder how their bass sound would sound like if they used different basses.
Before I dig myself into this rat-hole, let me just say, this topic is a very complicated discussion, that is the point. We gain, from pain. I will read all comments on this thread because it is an extremely good read for others, as well as myself.
Ok, here it goes...
One person in particular (my drummer), always prefer an Alembic sound to play off because it mix well with his drum tones. I am not sure I understood everything he explained, but Alembic does have an almost non-electric amplified acoustic sound.
Then when it comes to jamming a simple pattern (funky-stuff) with lots of slap, and pop, the Alembic sound to him lacks impact... The Marcus Miller Fender sound is expressed.
Alembics sound definitions, are almost too smooth for the edgy sound he demands to deploy.
Another example:
Sometimes I wonder what would Mark Adams of Slave bass sound (would sound like...) if he played Alembic on Just A Touch of Love, Slide,Sizzlin' Hot I wonder if it would have the same impact and punch?
And if that's not enough, I'd never heard anyone make a bass growl better than Mark (who plays a Fender). It's all his baby...
Copying is a form of flattery, and I must admit, I tried very hard to engineer my Alembic to growl like the Fender Mark plays, and failed miserably.
I would love to read more...