Shame, Dave, Roscoe is a fabulous player, and I really admire Eric Johnson as well, but of course they're from Texas!
With any luck, I'll NEVER own a Fender bass, but IF I did, I've played several Roscoe Beck five-strings, and they were all EXCELLENT. Fender and Roscoe chased the idea of a five-string equivalent to the classic, passive Jazz for several years, finally turning over the pickup design to Bill Lawrence. Believe me, he got it right! Ultralights, Gotoh bridge, interesting all passive switching system, really nice axe for a Fender . . .
And I'm DAMN sure not a 'frustrated guitar player' . . . be somebody, hang with your drummer!
J o e y