Jeff; as moderator I have on several occasions discouraged political threads and comments as outlined in the posting guidelines, and that discouragement remains my position on the mater. I recently edited a post by another club member to remove a disparaging remark of a political nature. It was perhaps an overreaction on my part to take that kind of action, but I have stated my position several times and I would have hoped that after last November that we could all agree to respect our fellow club members by not saying things that others will find to be attacks on their character.
For some, and understandably so, politics and religion are subjects that can be highly emotional. Events that are celebratory for some can be heart rending for others.
Many people worked very hard for the candidates who lost in November; and for some it is still an emotionally bitter defeat.
Our community is a close knit community, and our closeness is based on a common love and appreciation of music, and of Alembic instruments. It is my considered opinion as moderator that discussions and comments of a political nature will serve to loosen the bonds that make this community the place that it is. Many of our members, as has been stated by others in past discussions on this topic, hold this place as a refuge; they simply do not want to know the political affiliations or positions of their fellow club members.
There will be many members here that agree with your observation that things are refreshing; however, there will be many others who do not share that view, and some of them will be upset that you even brought it up. There will be some who won't say anything in response, but will just close the browser window and look for some other refuge.
I find it wholly understandable that you would want to share with your friends here how you feel about the political climate. But as moderator, for the above stated reasons, I just don't think it is a good idea. I have stated this many times in the past, and the feedback that I get is that the club as a whole finds this position to be reasonable.
I spend hours every day in political blogs, and if you like discussing politics, a political blog is a wonderful place to do so. The political blog I spend the most time in is for me and many others a community. But that place is a different world than our community here.
We have a wonderful community here and as moderator I imperfectly try within the limitations of my ability to help keep it so. I hope you find my position on this matter reasonable.
[edit: spelling]
(Message edited by davehouck on January 28, 2009)