I find myself drawn to 30+ year old instruments; not that age is what I look for first, but I always find myself gravitating towards the more 'experienced' ones...I've never been a real Fender guy but when I worked at a vintage shop I got to play some real old ones and they do feel different even from the best relics; you can't fake the aging of a maple neck, they have to absorb sweat!
Another example is my '60 Melody Maker...it's a transition one(had the lap steel pickups, just before they went to the skinny ones...)
Anyway, it was Gibson's student guitar but it's made of wood that we can't get now without paying huge...I've been offered three times what it sells for and turned it down; A. I didn't want to rip off a friend(and my drummer) B. it's one of those old guitars with 1000 songs in it...old guitars make you play new things and any rutbuster is good...
I do think that the prices now paid for '70's Fenders is stupid; those guitars and basses weren't that good 30+ years ago and aren't that much better now, unless lots of that plastic finish has fallen off and the wood dried out!
I could keep going, but I won't...Tony