Yeah, I find a lot of Fenders dead on the E string; I think it's the nature of a bolt neck in general unless it's bolted within an inch of it's life like a Musicman, which is still not completely even...I have a Fender that is pretty good, but find I have to compensate by hitting the E harder to even it out...Tony
Like any bolt on instrument there are good ones and not so good ones. I've owned a lot of basses over the years and I've found that different amps and different rooms punctuate the inconsistencies in the neck. I've played a few early 1960's Fender basses that people/shops wanted a boatload of money for that didn't blow my skirt up one bit. I've also played Mexi-Fenders that sounded amazing but felt terrible in my hands. As an exercise in what is possible I once took a Johnson P bass and outfitted it with a Badass II bridge, Seymour Duncan Antiquity II pickups, Hipshot ultralight tuners, and a brass nut. It sounded really damn good but it was brutal to play for 3+ hours a night. I only did one gig with that bass because it just hurt my hands to wrestle with it all night.
The only thing I am certain of is that I seem to have landed on my holy grail of tone and consistency with my Alembic basses and Mesa amplification. I should also note that my trusty Modulus Q4 has also remained a consistent and reliable tone giant for the last 20 years; it just produces a tone that I?m not necessarily looking for day to day.