The reason I prefer a mute switch on the instrument is back when, 20 years or so, the amps I was using didn't have the option of muting. So I started installing mute switches in the basses I used for theater work. It's a habit thing now. The amp I'm using, TC Electronic BG250 has a mute switch on the front panel. So a foot switch would work just as well but I am use to and prefer the switch on the instrument. Also, I have no problems modifying the bass. I believe I can do a tasteful job.