Sorry Rich, work has been busy the last few daze! Most short scales I have played are lacking in a nice solid E, as you mentioned, a boomy, undefined sound. I have always used heavy gage strings, regardless of scale, so I am out of that loop on different gages. The short-scale S1 I picked up a while ago has a very defined E, and if anything is too bright. It has standard issue Alembic short-scales on it and sounds great - when I take some of the edge off it. Mark King would love the sound this little bass makes. I got it, as I kept hearing such good things said about the short and medium scale Alembics, and they were right! Happy hunting on your string quest.